Sustainable Design Awards Toolkit
Section 2.4 Recycling
An overview of the process:
How people respond to recycled materials (taken from www.wastewatch.co.uk):
Myth: Recycled products are poor quality.
Reality: False. Aluminium and glass can be recycled repeatedly without a
loss in quality. Paper does suffer a reduction in quality as paper fibres shorten
with each reprocessing which limits the number of times it can be recycled. But
high quality paper is readily available and lower grades of paper are suitable for
many uses. Throughout the world, military and commercial aircraft use retread tyres,
as do time-critical courier services such as Federal Express.
Myth: Recycled products are too expensive.
Reality: Recycled products should not cost more but for some product areas
economies of scale do result in higher prices. That is why creating consumer demand
is so important to help lower prices.
Myth: Recycled products are not attractive.
Reality: Gone are the days of grey and grainy recycled paper. For many items
it is impossible to distinguish between recycled and non-recycled items.
Myth: Recycled products consume more energy and resources than a product made
from primary materials.
Reality: False. Many recycled materials
offer significant savings in terms of energy and water as well as
reductions in resource use. For example, manufacturing 1 tonne of
recycled paper results in 74% less air pollution and 34% less water
pollution than manufacturing a tonne of paper from virgin wood pulp.
Negative experience in the past with recycled products reinforces
the inertia. The view that "we have always bought that product, so
why change now?" is commonly expressed. Combating these myths and
prejudices can be accelerated through the provision of accurate information,
good practice case studies, demonstration projects and a supportive
national framework.
Plastics have a maximum recycled polymer content. This content will be smaller for more
structural items such as furniture and bigger for items such as plastic bags. This is
because the recycled polymer may be slightly contaminated. Also, as the polymer is recycled
its properties will be changed by the process. If too much recycled content is used fatigue
can lead to the material breaking. Sometimes legislation will state that recycled plastic
has to be laminated with a layer of virgin plastic. This often occurs in food packaging.
There are two types of recycling: closed loop and open loop. For closed-loop recycling
the producer has to collect the products when they are due to be thrown away. This can
be done through good consumer collection strategies, for example renting the product or
giving the consumer money for the products' return. A more popular route involves
recycling the waste produced during the manufacturing process. Production waste, for
example faulty mouldings, offcuts or flash that may have to be cut off each product when
it is removed from the mould, is easily collected. The producer can then recycle the
collected polymer and use the resulting recycled material to produce the same product.
Open-loop recycling uses recycled material gained from a variety of sources such as recycled
polymer sheet suppliers or through municipal waste. The recycled polymer is then used to
produce new unrelated products.
Material Recycling - Closed- Loop Recycling
Factories will often recycle plastic that is wasted due to problems such as flash or runners
produced during component production.
Other examples include:
Paper, steel cans, milk and juice carton and plastic recycling are also very popular.
Many businesses also directly recycle their products at their end of lives:
"Canon Business machines began recovering its more than 20 million used laser-printer
toner cartridges by working with a national delivery service to develop a U.S.
collection system. Cartridges are disassembled and combined with virgin material to
produce new units. GE Plastics buys back plastic material in flake or pellet form,
provided it is processed by acceptable regrind specifications and procedures."
(Machine Design, Feb 1993.)
Material Recycling – Open-Loop Recycling
Yemm+Hart are primarily a supplier of recycled sheet materials. They have used their own
sheets to produce products such as CD storage boxes, clipboards and cutting boards from
recycled polymers. They use the multicoloured ‘speckled’ qualities of the material to
add to the aesthetic qualities of the design. They also recycle more unusual materials;
the picture frame above right is laminated with recycled worn out car tyres.
Source: www.yemmhart.com
Smile Plastics is their UK competitor. “Smile Plastics is committed to sourcing and developing innovative ideas and markets for recycled materials, concentrating on transforming plastics waste into multicoloured sheets.”
Examples of recycled materials can be found on their website (
http://www.smile-plastics.co.uk)
|
|
Coffee table by James Oswald
Material: recycled HDPE made from disposable coffee cups. Material
selected for: aesthetic purposes.
Processes: cutting and routing.
|
|
"The design of a small coffee table using recycled polymers in a subtle and elegant manner.
The design aims to combine the visual qualities of the glass with the striking pattern of the
recycled polymer. The elliptical form is followed throughout the design creating a uniform feel
to both materials."
Taken from 2nd and 3rd year student work designing with recycled polymers from Made of Waste Ltd
© Loughborough University Department of Design and Technology, 1999
Composting:
Composting your food scraps and garden trimmings reduces the amount of waste that needs to be
disposed of. It also provides you with free rich soil that would otherwise have to be transported
to your house. Using compost can also greatly reduce the need for water, fertilisers and pesticides.
|
|
Symphony Environmental has developed a material that is inherently degradable (using unique EPI® DCP® (degradable additive) technology.) This solves the environmental problem caused by the 80,000 tonnes of waste polythene generated from refuse sack production...in the UK alone.
Source:
www.demi.org.uk
|
|
|
|
"The Compostable Keyboard", computer keyboard made of carrot pulp,
keys of spinach and celery. In nature, all waste converts to food.
Product wants commercial production and product consumption cycles
to evolve to be as efficient as nature.
Source:
www.designresource.org.uk
|
|
IDRA student first place 2001
Jason Iverson and Shayan Rafie
University of Washington Industrial Design Dept.
|
|
|
The Synchilla fleece top by Patagonia is made from recycled plastic bottles.
Source:
www.biothinking.com
|
|
The Remarkable Recycled Pen is made from a single plastic coffee cup. It also lasts four
times longer than most other ballpoints.
Source: www.biothinking.com
|
|
Seventh generation 2-Ply Toilet Paper is made from 80% post-consumer and 20% preconsumer recycled paper.
Source:
www.greenhomes.com
|
|
Disassembling products for recycling
What can happen at a product's end of life:
The diagram above shows how important ease of disassembly is to ensuring products are recycled or
reused rather than going into ‘disposal,’ i.e. landfill or incineration. Products should be made
from fewer polymer types to aid sorting and fewer components to aid separation. The automotive
industry is now leading the way by using fewer plastic types in cars.
|
|
The Louis 20 chair by Philippe Starck is made from only aluminium and polypropylene, both over 99% pure. The chair is held together with only five screws, making it very easy to disassemble and recycle.
Source:
www.biothinking.com
|
|
Disassembly computer aids
Ametide – A MEthodology for TIme Disassembly Estimation. In association with Renault, the
consortium on green design and manufacturing and 3S:
"Given that disassembly techniques, which include a lot of destructive
methods, are improving all the time, we assumed that designer has
no time to update his knowledge in disassembly. To prevent this we
set up a database easily updated from where we extract all the disassembly
techniques available corresponding to a fastener. Thus the designer
gets the panel of all possibilities for removing a part and can choose
which is the best depending on what the part is disassembled for."
A typical screen from the programme. Gives component name, mass and material type; the
fastening system used; pollution; method of disassembly and disassembly time:
Source: http://greenmfg.me.berkeley.edu/green/cad/ametide
SMART materials
|
|
A technological solution to the disassembly process is the use of shape-memory alloys (SMAs.) These can change shape at specified temperatures. Some types can also create force when they change shape. This force can be used to give ‘active disassembly’ where the SMAs force different components out of the assembly at different temperatures. More information on this technique can be found in the Inspirational current work section by Pete Simmons.
Source: Norman, Cubitt, Urry, Whittaker
'Advanced Design and Technology' Third Edition.
|
|
|
|
|
Ecodesign Tools
|
|
|
|
Toolkit Index
|
|